In a previous post I described my process for selecting historic paint colors for Victorian and Arts and Crafts era homes and businesses. Rather than relying on the historic color collections from modern paint manufacturers such as Benjamin Moore or Sherwin-Williams, we use our own collection of period color swatches and advertising for authentic Victorian and Arts and Crafts era color palettes. This way we can be sure to consider the same colors homeowners did 130 years ago and create an appropriate color palette. I also study the way house paints were mixed and tinted so I can better understand how the original paint colors appeared to make my color reports even more authentic.
My process for selecting colors palettes for older homes is quite simple. First, I read what designers and architects wrote about house colors and design in the 19th and early 2oth centuries. Andrew Jackson Downing, Samuel Sloan and many others wrote in detail about selecting paint colors and how they thought a paint scheme should be arranged. I can get a good idea how Victorian homeowners and designers picked their color palettes by working my way through these primary sources.
Second, I need to know how paint was mixed. When we read Downing’s descriptions of paint colors such as drab or fawn it is essential to know which pigments were used so we can imagine how the paint might have looked. Since painters tended to be a conservative lot who mixed paints using familiar recipes, I can look at slightly later color swatches to get some idea of older paint colors.
Learning about early paint recipes and pigments is also a reliable way to reconstruct early color palettes. 19th and early 20th century paints was mixed using four basic ingredients: linseed oil; white lead; turpentine and pigments. Many of the pigments used before 1875 were earth pigments, or pigments mined or refined from soil. In other words, earth pigments are pretty colored dirt.
Here are a few examples of pigments that were commonly used in the 19th century.
Other pigments, such as Prussian Blue and Chrome Green, were commonly used. Unlike earth pigments, these pigments were chemicals produced in factories. Although found in many paint recipes, many of these manufactured pigments were fugitive. This means they tended to fade or discolor in sunlight. This is why few 19th century houses were painted bright blue or purple since these paint recipes usually contained fugitive Prussian Blue.
Earth pigments were inexpensive and durable and widely used through the 19th century. Later on they began to be replaced by brighter, more vibrant colors made from the by-products of the petroleum industry. This is why the bright, saturated colors commonly used in the early 1900s on Colonial Revival homes look out of place on earlier Italianate and Gothic Revival examples.
For a look at part one of this post, click here.